If repeating a statement over and over again were a guarantee that the statement is true, then I would have to believe that Jim Garlow does not fear gays and liberals. He certainly goes on at length insisting that he has no such fear. But I suspect that the reason Garlow invited liberals to speak at his church was to exploit them for his own purposes. I doubt that he wants his flock to seriously entertain the notion that God might be okay with homosexuality.
Skyline Church, the Rancho San
Diego megachurch known for hosting conservative speakers such as Glenn
Beck and Texas Gov. Rick Perry, was harshly judged this week by a former
Episcopal bishop famed for defending gay marriage, including his own.
The Right Rev. Gene Robinson. Image via Wikimedia CommonsIn a column for The Daily Beast, the Right. Rev. Gene Robinson wrote about attending a Sunday service at Skyline and finding a mood that turned dark.
“In between the uplifting songs, the message is: They’re coming to
get us. One by one, the speakers lay out the parameters of the siege
under which Christians live, attacked by liberal and godless forces on
every side.”
In a piece headlined “Even After Hobby Lobby, the Religious Right is Still Terrified,” Robinson wrote:
Every message, action and gesture seems calculated to
ratchet up the anxiety of those who are listening. And then it’s over.
Just like that.
I honestly don’t know how typical such a service is among
evangelicals, bent on making people fearful, but if you left that
service feeling hopeful, at peace with God, and eager to help the poor
and needy, then you weren’t paying attention.
Now a senior fellow at the liberal Center for American Progress, Robinson concluded his 1,100-word column posted Sunday with this:
“Anti-gay sentiment is waning in American society, and with that
forward progress, conservative churches will see a loss of credibility
and a diminished effectiveness of their fear-mongering. That is as it
should be. Neither the church nor the state is served by it.”
On Tuesday, Skyline senior pastor Jim Garlow responded.
Answering a Times of San Diego request for comment, Garlow said: “We
did not know the writer was in the audience on that Sunday morning
service. We did invite him to a Sunday night service.” Here is Garlow’s full response to Robinson, which he termed “my thoughts.”...
Conservative
evangelicals have internalized a besiegement narrative that doesn’t
change even when they win political victories. But fear has no place in a
properly Christian worldview.
There
is nothing intimidating about the building, other than its sheer size
and the many millions of dollars it took to build it. In fact, it is one
of the most welcoming places I’ve ever been. This conservative,
evangelical megachurch, just outside San Diego, is a hive of activity on
a Sunday morning. Upon entering, I’m drawn into the sophisticated café
that makes Starbucks look like a 10-year-old’s sidewalk lemonade stand. I
get my latte and am assured that I am welcome to take it with me to my
seat in the church. I find a seat, which is plush and comfortable, and
sure enough, there’s a cup holder for my coffee.
I am struck by
the starkness of the worship space: no windows, all black, no cross or
stained glass, and not a single sign that this is a place of worship. A
drum trap set is the only thing on the massive stage. It’s hard to tell,
really, when the service starts; it just seems to grow organically,
with additional people coming onto the stage over the course of 15
minutes, everyone dressed in jeans and comfortable clothing. The sense
of expectation grows minute by minute.
The crowd gathering in the
congregation is old and young. Some members are alone, some coupled, and
lots of families, with kids in tow. And virtually all white. Everyone
seems excited to be here. When things actually begin, it is as
professional as any Broadway show, with fantastic music by a small band,
and everyone is singing. Although there is a brief prayer early on, the
service seems oddly devoid of any mention of God, much less Jesus. And
within the first 10 minutes, the head minister announces that the time
has come for what we’ve all been waiting for: the collection, the chance
to give for the work and ministry of this place. And everyone cheers.
That’s right, cheers! Wild applause, enthusiastic delight at the chance
to contribute to the ministry.
If
you left that service feeling hopeful, at peace with God, and eager to
help the poor and needy, then you weren’t paying attention.
But
soon, the mood turns dark. In between the uplifting songs, the message
is: they’re coming to get us. One by one, the speakers lay out the
parameters of the siege under which Christians live, attacked by liberal
and godless forces on every side. An African-American minister from New
York describes a change in policy in New York City to disallow churches
to hold services in public schools, and his message is, “Beware. What’s
happening in New York is headed your way! Get ready!”
The sermon
is delivered by a guest preacher, whose main point seems to be the evils
of feminism and sexual immorality. In the 40-minute “sermon,” there is
hardly a mention of the Divine. “God” shows up about 30 minutes in, and
Jesus is mentioned only once, at the last minute. The senior pastor
delivers an additional message, imploring those present to return that
evening for a debate about homosexuality (the reason I’m there—and to
their credit, both sides are being represented). His explicit message
is, “Come tonight! I cannot prepare you for the onslaught of immorality
and anti-Christian fervor if you don’t come! There is a battle underway
for your souls, and I intend to outfit you for a holy war!” Every
message, action and gesture seems calculated to ratchet up the anxiety
of those who are listening. And then it’s over. Just like that.
I
honestly don’t know how typical such a service is among evangelicals,
bent on making people fearful, but if you left that service feeling
hopeful, at peace with God, and eager to help the poor and needy, then
you weren’t paying attention. It is no wonder to me that many
conservative, Christian people are fearful, and believe that there is a
war on religion (especially Christians) in this country. After all, it
is drummed into them every week...
The Rev. Frank Schaefer, a United Methodist minister, was defrocked after officiating at the wedding of his son Tim.Credit
Gabriella Demczuk/The New York Times
Father
and son had always been close, from the moment Tim Schaefer was born,
six weeks premature, with blood poisoning, a weak heart and lungs, and a
doctor who thought he would not make it through the night.
His
father, the Rev. Frank Schaefer, a United Methodist minister, thought
of his eldest son as a miracle child, saved by some combination of
medicine and prayer, saved for something special.
“We
couldn’t even touch him; he was in an incubator, and we had to reach in
with latex gloves through those holes in the sides,” Mr. Schaefer said.
“I begged God to please save his life.”
Their
bond was such that, years later, facing a choice between upholding his
church’s teaching and affirming his son’s sexual orientation, Frank
chose to endanger his own career by officiating at his son’s same-sex
wedding. The actions that followed — a rebellion in his congregation, a
church trial, a defrocking and then, last month, a reinstatement —
have made the Schaefers symbols of the conundrum facing much of
American Christianity: How does religious doctrine on homosexuality
respond to the longings for spirituality and community from congregants
and family members who are gay?...
When did the loudmouths of the American right become such a bunch of fraidy-cats and professional victims? Or is it all just an act?
The hysteria over plans for an innocuous Muslim community center in Lower Manhattan -- two blocks from Ground Zero, amid an urban hodgepodge of office buildings, eateries and strip clubs -- is wildly out of proportion. It would be laughable if it didn't threaten to do great harm to the global campaign against Islamic terrorism.
It is by now firmly established that the project, dubbed Park51, is promoted by a peacenik Muslim cleric whose sermons often sound a bit like the musings of new-age guru Deepak Chopra. It is also undisputed fact that the imam in question, Feisal Abdul Rauf, is such a moderate that the U.S. government regularly sends him as an emissary to Muslim countries to preach peace, coexistence and dialogue.
Yet right-wing commentators and politicians have twisted themselves in knots to portray the Park51 project as a grievous assault -- and "the American people" as victims. Victims of what? Rauf's sinister plot to despoil the city with a fitness center, a swimming pool and -- shudder -- a space for the performing arts?
The whole "controversy" is ridiculous. Yet conservatives who should know better are doing their best to exploit widespread ignorance about Islam by transforming it into fear and anger. They imply, but don't come right out and say, that it was Islam itself that attacked the United States on Sept. 11, 2001, rather than an extremist fringe that espouses what the vast majority of the world's Muslims consider a perversion of the faith. They paint Park51 as a "victory dance" over the hallowed ground where thousands of Americans died -- never mind that there wouldn't even be a sight line between the building and Ground Zero -- and suggest that the project, even though it would be run by an imam who's practically a flower child, could somehow serve as a recruiting center for terrorists.
Message to anyone who will listen: You're a victim. Be very afraid.
In the process, this anti-mosque pitchfork brigade is surely recruiting terrorists left and right. As Ahmad Moussalli, a professor at the American University of Beirut, told the Los Angeles Times: "Rejecting this has become like rejecting Islam itself." All the Islamophobic rhetoric tends to reinforce the jihadists' main argument, which is that the United States and the West seek to destroy the faith held dear by more than 1 billion souls. ad_icon
The thing is, though, that the manufactured brouhaha over the Park51 project is part of a larger pattern in which the far right embraces victimhood and stokes fear. The faction that likes to portray itself as a bunch of John Waynes and "mama grizzlies," it turns out, spends an awful lot of time cowering in the corner and complaining about how beastly everyone else is being...
PITTSBURGH — Republicans have turned to terrifying people in the debate over overhauling the health care system because the GOP has no political clout to fight it, former President Bill Clinton told a gathering of progressive bloggers on Thursday.
Clinton was president when the Democrats made their last major effort to change the health care system. The big difference now, Clinton said, is that Democrats have a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate as well as control of the House.
The former president called "crazy" the charges that promoting living wills and other end-of-life planning is somehow promoting death.
Clinton spoke at the opening session of the Netroots Nation convention, a gathering of politically progressive bloggers and other online activists.
He urged the crowd to support President Barack Obama on health care reform, along with climate change legislation and other reforms.
"The president needs your help and the cause needs your help," Clinton said. "We have to preserve this progress majority now."
However, he advised them that change may not come as fast as they want and that they may have to accept smaller victories as they continue to work for their goals...
